Hot Runner vs. Cold Running Moulds: Differences and Comparison
Injection moulding is a popular manufacturing process that produces plastic components. This process has two main types of tooling designs: hot runner and cold runner. A hot runner mould uses a heated runner to transfer molten thermoplastic or polymer to the mould cavity where the final product takes on its shape. On the other hand, a cold runner mould uses an unheated runner channel to transfer the molten material from the machine nozzle to the mould cavity.
Hot Runner Definition and Comparison to Cold Running Moulds
A hot runner mould uses a manifold as a heating element to ensure uniformity in the temperature of the heating cylinder and runner. The parts produced by hot runner moulds are more precise in their dimensions than those from cold runner moulds. Compared to the cold runner mould, the hot runner mould produces more parts per unit time.
Advantages of Hot Runner Compared to Cold Running Moulds
1. No Need for Robotics: Hot runner moulds do not require the help of robotics to separate the runner from the mould, unlike cold runner moulds.
2. Precision: The parts produced by hot runner moulds are more precise in their dimensions than those from cold runner moulds.
3. Large Volume Production: Larger volumes and sizes of parts can be produced by hot runner moulds.
Disadvantages of Hot Runner Compared to Cold Running Moulds
1. Higher Maintenance Costs: Hot runner moulds have higher maintenance costs compared to cold runner moulds.
2. Material Limitation: Hot runner moulds do not suit some heat-sensitive thermoplastic materials compared to cold runner moulds.
3. Difficulty in Colour Changes: It is difficult to make colour changes in hot runner moulds.
Cold Running Moulds Definition and Comparison to Hot Runner
Cold running moulds use unheated runners to convey molten thermoplastic material from the nozzle to the mould or cavities. Cold running moulds are sometimes preferred over hot runner moulds because of the low setup and maintenance cost.
Advantages of Cold Running Moulds Compared to Hot Runner
1. Material Versatility: Cold running moulds accommodate a variety of thermoplastics compared to hot runner moulds.
2. Cost-Effective: Cold running moulds are cost-effective compared to hot runner moulds.
3. Quick Design and Colour Changes: Cold running moulds allow for quick changes in design or colour.
Disadvantages of Cold Running Moulds Compared to Hot Runner
1. Waste Production: Cold running moulds produce more waste than hot runner moulds.
2. Tolerance: Cold running moulds produce parts with lower tolerances than those of hot runner moulds.
3. Production Speed: The production process of cold running moulds is slower than hot runner moulds. Therefore, a lesser number of parts can be produced via cold running moulds.
Comparison Table Between Hot Runner and Cold Runner
Table 1: Attributes when comparing cold runner vs. hot runner moulds
| Attributes | Hot Runner | Cold Runner |
|---|---|---|
| Allows quick changes in design or colour | No | Yes |
| The high degree of tolerance | Yes | No |
| Works with a variety of thermoplastics | No | Yes |
| High maintenance cost | Yes | No |
| Produces large volume of parts | Yes | No |
| Uses unheated runner | No | Yes |
| Molten thermoplastic or polymer is used | Yes | Yes |
Hot Runner vs. Cold Runner: Cost Comparison
Hot runner moulds have a higher setup and maintenance cost compared to cold runner moulds. However, the high rate of waste production in cold runner moulds can counterbalance any potential cost savings if the waste is not managed correctly.
Hot Runner vs. Cold Runner: Speed Comparison
A hot runner mould produces more parts per unit time than cold runner moulds due to the need to separate the runner from the mould and recycle the runner to avoid waste.
Hot Runner vs. Cold Runner: Volume Comparison
Hot runner moulds can produce a larger number of unheated runners in cold runner moulds results in more waste material. This makes hot runner moulds more efficient and suitable for large-scale production.
Alternatives to Hot Runner and Cold Runner Moulds
There are other alternatives to hot runner and cold runner moulds, including:
1. Valve Gate System: This is a type of hot runner mould that controls the flow of molten plastic into the mould cavity using a valve. It eliminates the need for a runner system, reduces waste, and provides better control over the flow of molten plastic.
2. Insulated Runner Mould: This is a type of cold runner mould that reduces waste by insulating the runner system. It helps to keep the material in the runner hot and prevents it from cooling down and solidifying.
3. Three-Plate Mould: This is a type of cold runner mould that uses three plates to separate the runner from the part. It allows for easy removal of the runner from the mould and minimises waste.
Conclusion
In summary, hot runner moulds and cold runner moulds are two types of injection moulding systems used to produce plastic parts. Each type has its advantages and disadvantages, and the choice between them depends on the specific production requirements. Hot runner moulds are more expensive but produce more precise parts with shorter lead times, while cold runner moulds are cheaper and more versatile in terms of materials. It’s important to understand these differences and consider the alternatives before selecting the appropriate mould design for your project.
FAQs
1. What is the main difference between hot runner and cold runner moulds?
Hot runner moulds use a heated runner to transfer molten material, while cold runner moulds use an unheated runner channel.
2. Why are hot runner moulds preferred for high-precision parts?
Hot runner moulds are preferred for their ability to produce precise parts with high tolerances.
3. What is the cost advantage of cold runner moulds?
Cold runner moulds are cost-effective and have lower setup and maintenance costs.
4. Can cold runner moulds accommodate various thermoplastic materials?
Yes, cold runner moulds can work with a variety of thermoplastics.
5. Which mould type is suitable for large-scale production?
Hot runner moulds are more efficient for large-scale production due to their ability to reduce waste.
READY TO START?
To get your components or sub-assemblies manufactured by us, you can call our team on 01543 462 561 or send an email enquiry to [email protected]. Our team of experts will be in contact within hours to help you with your project.
We can advise on the design of your product to suit the manufacturing processes required. We can organise tooling for you and manage the project for you so that you receive conforming parts at a competitive price. And we’ll keep doing that for you for as many years as you need us to.
